Discussion about this post

User's avatar
Francyne Mixon's avatar

Thank you! You have activated the thinking mode. 🤔

Expand full comment
Jordan Hughes's avatar

This is a wonderful selection of quotes. Thank you!

They resonate for me, as I have been reflecting on the dominance of prevailing conventional wisdom. It seems that evolution has equipped human brains with the capacity to identify sources of authority, in the sphere of belief systems no less than in that of social power. Consequently, most people develop representations of epistemic authority, or reliable guides to what one should believe, early in childhood and continue to rely on those models throughout their lives. Very few people can even identify, much less question, their fundamental assumptions.

It seems that the normal way people distinguish between fact and falsehood is by deferring to the epistemic authorities to which they have delegated authorship of their primary beliefs. In other words, it's virtually impossible for most people to think for themselves.

Typically, a cardinal rule established by those who think within genuinely original frames of reference is that people should think for themselves. Naturally, this precept becomes assimilated along with the epistemic authority granted to the originators of influential doctrines, so the followers become convinced that, having successfully internalized the ideas of their intellectual leaders, they too have become original thinkers.

Awash in self-appointed experts, intelligent people have generally come to confuse the ability to select from among a multitude of opinions with the ability to critically analyze arguments and build a framework of first principles by which to distinguish between sense and nonsense.

An emperor with no clothes, masquerading as appareled by reason, thus rules the realm of foundational beliefs entrenched within most modern and enlightened minds. Enthroned at the root of each mind's hierarchy of accepted precepts sits a naked emperor shrouded in the garb of credulity, which always stylishly imitates the haut couture designs fashioned by prevailing purveyors of epistemic authority.

Expand full comment
13 more comments...

No posts